Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments Redux

Good game. Hours of twists and turns. You decide what the punishment is for the crime.

Got it on sale and so far I like what I see. For people who say they cant get passed the first case. You have to pick the ring up off the evidence table andd click on the engraving in 3 diff places then ask the suspect about it. You have to search newspapers at your apartment for the name on ring before talking to him.

Please remember this an older game. With that being said, it's great for what it is. A detective deduction walkthrough. There are some bugs, however I was able to play through it's entirety. (uninstall - reinstall) I played through twice, choosing the different outcomes. Good for achievements, good for passing the time, and enjoyable for about the 8-10 hrs it takes to beat. Sherlock Holmes Stories (basically) buy on sale worth no more than $5 or you can wait for bundle and get the devils daughter as I did for $10, which builds on this games mechanics as well as giving you an overall story outside the cases 3/5

On the last mission i needed to use my "Imagination" to see how a crime scene played out but i never got objective to start it. Some of the cases are interesting but last mission ruined this game.

Closest Ive been to feeling that LA Noire feeling again. Two cases felt a little handholdy but the rest genuinely made me stop for a while and rethink my accusations and reasonings. Maybe too short for full price, definitely buy if on sale.